Music can help people with dementia recover some aspects of their memory, feel calmer, and boost their mood—and evidence of this is growing each day. However, what is it about music that has such a profound effect on our brains? And is this effect long-lasting?
You might have come across a video of an older person with dementia where a particular piece of music makes them sway to the music, bringing back a flood of memories, or despite not remembering their family members, they start playing the notes to a song they used to know on the piano or violin.
This phenomenon is what leaves many people puzzled about the neurological disorder that is dementia. How can someone forget their own children’s names but remember something as complex as a classical piece of music?
That question was one of the many we aimed to seek an answer to in our April podcast “In Conversation: Investigating the power of music for dementia”. Joining the conversation this month were Dr. Kelly Jakubowski, assistant professor in music psychology at Durham University, and Beatie Wolfe, singer, songwriter, and ambassador for the charity Music for Dementia.
Whether lyrical or instrumental, music is a creative combination of rhythm, harmony, and the expression of emotion. Numerous studies can also attest to its many health benefits.
A
Besides its physiological benefits, research has also found evidence of music’s positive impact on cognitive health.
A recent study suggested that practicing and actively listening to music may help slow the decline of cognitive function in people ages 62–78 years. The researchers found that engaging in musical activities increased the brain’s gray matter in some areas, which increased its neuroplasticity—the brain’s ability to rewire itself, which is crucial for learning, and forming memories.
In terms of actively practicing music, a 2023 study also suggested that long-term music training may provide potential functional benefits to the brain and help keep it young.
Such findings make music a potentially powerful tool in treating dementia, which is characterized by an array of symptoms that include memory loss and difficulties with thinking, language, and problem-solving.
One other way music may help cognitive health is by becoming a medium for connection. Multiple
“I feel like music is the most powerful instant connector, almost of any experience and, and of the arts,” said Beatie.
The singer/songwriter said she believes the arts, in general—not just music—can bemedicinallypowerful, extending its power beyond a form of entertainment.
“Because [music is] all-pervasive, it’s not something that requires the person to get up and dance or draw. Someone can just absorb the frequencies and the words and this whole soundscape. For me definitely, music was always this kind of powerful resource that I use to feel good. [W]hen you have seen the responses I’ve seen to music, you have infinite respect and appreciation for it,” she said.
However, as much as sound and music have an impact on our health, the lack of it—silence—is just as, if not more impactful. A
In fact, research has also shown the detriment of too much noise and loud sounds on cognitive health. A
Our guest Beatie shared her thoughts on how complete silence impacted her by recounting her experience in what was the world’s quietest room where she recorded her “Raw Space” album in the Bell Labs anechoic chamber.
“It was one of the most profound experiences I think I’ve ever had, and it’s something that I continually return to. Even now it feels like it’s almost become more relevant today. As the world’s just got noisier, both literally in terms of sonically but also informationally—we’re getting bombarded from all angles, with social media and notifications, and all of these things that are hitting us that are kind of frazzling us,” she said.
THE QUIETEST ROOM“You feel silence; it’s almost like you feel this entire sensory reset, and your nervous system calms down and you hear sound in this pure way with no echo and no reverb and no enhancements. And you realize [that] we use technology almost now so excessively, to iron out all of these things that are actually what make us human beings to begin with?”
— Beatie Wolfe, singer/songwriter
Beatie seemed to enjoy the experience much more than most people do and ended up spending quite a few hours in that very chamber.
“I was told that I’d probably be able to stay in there for 15 minutes, because you hear the blood rushing through your veins, and the engineers typically had to take breaks because it was so intense. I ended up spending, I think it was 100 hours or more,” she said.
“I ended up being in there for the first time for several hours, just found it so calming, maybe I’m an anomaly. But I had the opposite reaction to [the] freakout that people have, which I think is also about really being with yourself. I do think there’s an element of it in the chamber, you are there very much with yourself, there are no distractions, there’s nothing to pull you out of that internal space,” she continued.
On the topic of recalling song lyrics but not remembering one’s own children’s names for people with dementia, Dr. Guite drew attention to repetition and how music can activate many brain regions and networks simultaneously.
“We’ve talked about this, the globality of music in the brain, but the repetition of a child’s name is something that’s happened through life, whereas the song may be kind of once a month or, once a year. How can we explain that?” she asked.
Dr. Jakubowski said the ability to fill in words of songs was related to procedural memory.
“So procedural memories [are] something like remembering motor sequences, like being able to ride a bike, right? So, when people might not have this kind of semantic memory anymore for names and places, they still have this kind of memory for the motor sequence of singing along lyrics, probably because they’ve sang along to that song lots of times before, or at least sang along in their minds lots of times before to that piece of music,”
she said.
She also said that the brain may spare certain parts of this type of memory, which could explain why some people are able to recall lyrics or play an old song on an instrument even though they have dementia.
“[I]f someone had played the piano previously, often they can continue to play those familiar pieces on the piano, even quite far into the disease,” she said.
In 2014, Beatie established a research project called “The Power of Music” in a group of care homes in the U.K. run by the Priory Group.
It is easy to see in the video and snapshots of that experience how the people with dementia in those care homes start tapping their feet, clapping their hands, and singing along, some with their eyes shining.
She told us about how it all started with the experience of playing original songs in English in a Portuguese nursing home.
“[I]n the case of my father-in-law, I was going to play just to him, but I ended up playing to this whole ward of 100 or so people with dementia and Alzheimer’s, who were all Portuguese. None of them spoke English apart from this relative. And I was playing new songs, songs in English that they didn’t have any prior connection with. And I was seeing people singing along as much as they could, and clapping and waking up,” she said.
This gave Beatie the idea to test out the hypothesis that music itself was powerful, whether you were already familiar with it or not. She was inspired by neurologist Oliver Sacks who predicted in his book Musicophilia that prior knowledge of music was not a pre-requisite for its influence.
When she played original songs to people in the care homes in the U.K., one particular song’s effect on the audience stood out.
Dr. Jakubowski weighed in on why she thinks the song ‘Wish’ was a particular hit with the residents of the care home Beatie visited.
“[S]o, in particular, Beatie uses quite short phrases. [Y]ou can almost predict what the next word or the next rhyme might be, which is really nice for encouraging people to try and sing along. There’s a lot of repetition. So you start to anticipate, and so it provides this nice scaffold, for people to be able to join along,” she said.
Apart from rhyme and alliteration, Dr. Jakubowski said the very clear beat is another contributing element.
“The tempo of the piece of music is actually very close to what we call the sort of preferred tempo for humans. We have what we call a sort of spontaneous motor tempo, which is, basically if I asked you to just tap a beat without hearing anything, usually, people will tap around 120 beats per minute, which is around the speed of that piece of music,” she said.
“[I]t’s a very easy piece to clap along with because we feel comfortable clapping at that speed. So I think that invites participation as well,” she added.
Dr. Jakubowski also said that the structure of the music makes it easy to follow.
“[I]f you don’t have complicated lyrics, and you occasionally have this, ‘oh, oh,’ that’s quite easy to grasp,” she said.
Dr. Jakubowski has been researching MEAMS, or music-evoked autobiographical memories, in general, but believes there are various implications for its connection to dementia as well.
She first talked about music’s chain effect on memory recall.
“When music or any cue activates a memory, that can then activate other memories that are related to that. So, the idea is that, if music can evoke a memory related to that music, that might also help us to bring back other memories from that time period or memories that are linked,” she said.
In one of her works, Dr. Jakubowski compared music to other types of cues for autobiographical memories.
“We found quite consistently across several studies that music tends to, across the board, evoke more positive memories from our lives than other cues. So I think this is one clear potential therapeutic benefit— [it] is that music seems to be a particularly effective cue for bringing us back to positive memories from our lives. And this actually seems to be even boosted further in older adults,” she said.
Dr. Jakubowski hopes this encourages more research to be done in this area and to see whether these findings are valid for people with dementia, especially in the later stages of the condition.
Memories, music, and identity
Dr. Jakubowski also explained how music can help give back people with dementia a sense of identity which often starts to slip away with lost memory.
“I think beyond that, the importance of autobiographical memories is that when we are able to recall a snippet of something from our lives, it really enhances our sense of identity and personhood, and reminds us of who we are and where we came from. And that’s quite important to people who have some sense of, semblance of memory loss, because then they feel kind of stuck in the moment, and they can’t reconnect with their past selves, which can then impact their mental health,” she said.
“This sense of reconnecting, sense of personhood, and past also influences carers as well as family members. So seeing that glimpse of the person you used to know is really, really important. For family members and carers, [this] helps them to realize this is still a person, they have a past and they have this rich history.”
— Dr. Kelly Jakubowski
Dr. Jakubowski noted that while music’s immediate benefit to health is quite apparent, to talk about a lasting benefit, consistent exposure is needed.
“[If] you hear music, you can’t expect there to be a lasting benefit forever, for years later, because you heard one song, three years ago. [H]aving more sustained engagement with some kind of music has more benefit than hearing music and then never hearing it again,” she said.
She also pointed out that people can engage with music in various ways.
“[E]ven listening to recorded music, in a kind of regular way, has lasting benefits for people with dementia— reducing agitation, reducing apathy, improving mood, sometimes enhancing [a] sense of identity, and so on. So I think, there [are] different ways you can engage with music,” she said.
Dr. Jakubowski underscored that music therapy may also have potential downsides in the treatment of dementia.
“There are potential downsides of music for any person regardless of whether they have dementia, in that occasionally music can be, for instance, linked to a traumatic memory from your life,” she said.
“[E]ven if it’s not a traumatic memory, it could sort of remind one of a funeral or loss of a family member. So, we need to be careful when we’re thinking about selecting music that we think about these things,” she continued.
She also touched on preference and all the different genres of music out there. This may produce unwanted effects, especially for people with dementia. She said music therapists have to think carefully about selecting the music they use in their sessions.
“[If] someone absolutely hates some music, it’s less likely to be effective for managing agitation and mood. This comes back to what we talked about at the very beginning of the conversation that sometimes sounds in our environment can be detrimental and annoying. So we don’t want to make people listen to music that they don’t particularly like, or don’t connect to [w]here they may have a negative reaction,” she said.
Likes and dislikes aside, such experiences are a testament to music’s power on health and well-being. Whether it can actually help delay the progression of dementia is a topic that needs further study, however
In ending, I’d like to leave our readers with one question: What is that one song that never fails to trigger an emotional response for you — whether it’s bringing back memories from the happiest day in your life or reminding you of a crushing heartbreak?
Source - Medical News Today
No comments:
Post a Comment