Not everyone is as upbeat about the recent results. MNT reached out to Deepak Nair, MD, a neurologist at OSF HealthCare who was not involved in the research. “Unfortunately, the study results are not quite as exciting as we would like.”

Although gantenerumab showed an impressive ability to remove amyloid protein plaques, he explained, “there was no statistically significant impact on clinical ratings of cognitive performance.”

“This is similar to other agents that have been shown to reduce the burden of amyloid plaque in patients with mild cognitive improvement or early stage Alzheimer’s disease,” Nair explained.

He also shared “serious concerns about the role of amyloid plaque in Alzheimer’s disease.” As we mentioned, the amyloid hypothesis of Alzheimer’s disease is still just that: a hypothesis.

“Recent revelations about falsified data in early Alzheimer’s research have raised serious concerns about the role of amyloid plaque in Alzheimer’s disease,” he told MNT. He also raised concerns about so-called amyloid-related imaging abnormalities (ARIA).

ARIA are side effects of anti-amyloid therapies that produce abnormal brain signals on MRI scans. They include fluid accumulation or microhemorrhages. “In the various studies of anti-amyloid drugs, the rate of ARIAs has affected 20–25% of patients,” Nair told us.

According to Nair, symptoms can include:

  • headache
  • confusion
  • nausea and vomiting
  • difficulty walking
  • worsening cognition

In the recent gantenerumab study, the rates of ARIA were particularly high, possibly due to the increased dosage. Two participants left the study due to these brain scan abnormalities, although they recovered fully once the drug had been stopped.

“Alzheimer’s disease, like all neurodegenerative diseases, is a highly complex process which affects the most complex organ system,” Nair concluded. “There is potential here, but we have much more to learn.”

“The accelerating rise in dementia cases presents a profound challenge, placing immense strain on families and demanding significant resources from state and federal governments,” Vercammen told MNT.

“In this context, studies like the one discussed are important, pushing the dialogue on dementia forward and bringing us closer to effective solutions,” he said.

Talking about next steps, Vercammen continued, “we must continue to prioritize large-scale, randomized clinical trials that encompass diverse populations at different stages of the disease in order to fully understand both the potential rewards and risks of any future treatments.”

Source - Medical News Today